First you.
I am not addressing every reader, but some of you need to hear this. The you I am thinking of is not every christian. You are not every evangelical. But you are one of them. There are many of you. I have heard your voice many times.
And now me.
I am not every gay woman. But I am one of them. There are many of me. I am the woman sitting beside you in church. I am the quiet one, the one that’s hard to get to know. I am hard to get to know because I am guarding a secret that I feel ashamed of here. I feel free to voice it outside of church, where I receive a freeing indifference or acceptance, but here, in church, my secret is cloaked in shame – the very place where I am meant to be freed from that. Here, I am silenced. And inside I am angry.
I am angry that in 2015 the place where I am most afraid to say I am gay is in the church; that the church is the place I feel least safe from homophobia. Here, you see my sexuality as an issue. You do not see the person behind the passage. Here, I feel ashamed of my attractions, of my need for touch, my need to belong. So often you are horrified or embarrassed if I express attraction to someone of the same sex while I must listen to your casual lust over Poldark, George Clooney and other men who are not your husband. These double standards seem invisible to you.
I am angry that you tell me I must be celibate (which I am, by the way. Not that it’s any of your business), while you elevate marriage and family. You strive for and celebrate your autonomous family units while telling me I can’t have it, but without giving me any alternatives. You tell me I must be celibate but you don’t help me to know what to do with this body. This body that is alive and human, that feels, that wants and yearns. You tell me don’t. You tell me about my sin, but that is where you leave me. You assume it is OK to ask me about my sex life, my sexual history, whether I watch porn, when you would never dream of being so grossly intrusive to a straight person. It’s important to make sure I am sticking to my don’ts. You intrude upon my privacy, but you do not help me.
I am angry that whether or not I am sexually active is seen as a marker for the status of my soul.
I am angry that so many of you put so much energy into fighting against gay people having equal rights, while enjoying all of those rights yourselves as married people without seeing the hypocrisy of that. You talk about the ‘gay agenda’ like it’s some kind of mass sorcery designed to corrupt your children. You do not understand this group of marginalised, shamed people who have been discriminated against for their entire history, trying to gain a voice, equality and recognition of their fundamental humanity. You have never got to know us. There is little understanding of heterosexual privilege within church walls – the idea that your automatic haves can make you blind to those who have not.
I am angry that you go to gay pride marches to pray, even if you are not so extreme that you would hold up a placard. Why have you gone there to pray? Do you assume that these people who are open about being gay, who are protesting for human rights, who are daring to say no to shame, are intrinsically further from God than you? Have you considered how much more powerful it would be to get to know one of these people? To have a real friendship? To find out why they have to fight to be proud? Perhaps then you will see how you are just the same. Just as far from God, or just as close.
I am angry that many gay evangelicals feel shamed into rejecting the label of gay or lesbian, because, we are told, our identity is in Christ, not our sexuality. Why then is it OK for you to name your identity as a man, a woman, a wife, a teacher, a dancer, a lawyer, a mother or any other facet of personhood, without that negating your identity in Christ? Instead we are told to describe ourselves as ‘having SSA’ (same sex attraction) as if we are afflicted with a disease. We are not diseased.
I am angry that even within the church, it is a constant battle for me to believe I am acceptable to God because of all the years of receiving the message that I am unacceptable just by being me, whether or not I act on my secret feelings. I have to work hard to remember that Jesus is not like this. Jesus loves the outcasts and the marginalised. Jesus has always welcomed those that others rejected. Jesus is a rebel, a radical, a rule-breaker. He loves people passionately and extravagantly and in wildly unexpected ways. I am angry that so often I have to get past you to get back to Him.
I am most angry that when a non-Christian gay person hears the word evangelical, they assume they will be rejected. I am angriest of all that often they are right. Jesus’ love is hidden and shrouded in the cloak of this scapegoating, and because of this obsession with one sin, millions of people will never look to the church for love and belonging because of their sexuality. About this, I am livid and broken-hearted.
Finally, I am angry with myself that I am a coward. That I am too afraid to voice these things. That I am too afraid to speak up and so I perpetuate the culture that keeps people like me closeted.
I am angry that I do not have a voice.
But here, today, I do.